Notes to Nineteenth Century Geometry

Notes to the Supplementary Document

1 The informal characterization of n-manifolds in the supplement is not altogether accurate and may cover some far-fetched monsters that we do not wish to cover with this concept. For readers who have a smattering of topology the following characterization is preferable.

(a) Let M be a set of points. Pick a collection of partially overlapping subsets of M, or patches, such that every point of M lies in at least one patch.

(b) If U is a patch of M, there is a one-one mapping f of U onto an open space of Rn, whose inverse we denote by f−1. (Rn denotes here the collection of all real number n-tuples, with the standard topology generated by the open balls.) f is a coordinate system or chart of M; the k-th number in the n-tuple assigned by a chart f to a point P in f's domain is called the k-th coordinate of P by f; the k-th coordinate function of chart f is the real-valued function that assigns to each point of the patch its k-th coordinate by f.

(c) There is a collection A of charts of M which contains at least one chart defined on each patch of M and is such that, if g and h belong to A, the composite mappings hg−1 and gh−1 — known as coordinate transformations — are differentiable to every order wherever they are well defined. (Denote the real number n-tuple (a1, ... , an) by a. hg−1 is well defined at a if a is the valued assigned by g to some point P of M to which h also assigns a value. Suppose that the latter value h(P) = (b1,...., bn) = b; then, b = hg−1(a). Since hg−1 maps a region of Rn into Rn, it makes sense to say that hg−1 is differentiable.) Such a collection A is called an atlas for M.

(d) A given atlas A for M can be extended in one and only one way to a maximal atlas Amax as follows: add to A every one-one mapping g of a subset of M onto an open set of Rn which, combined with any chart h of A, satisfies the condition of differentiability stated under (c).

(e) M is given the weakest Hausdorff topology that makes every chart g in Amax into a homeomorphism. (A topological space is said to be Hausdorff if any two points in it have open neighborhoods that do not overlap.)

The pair (M,A) is an n-manifold.

Copyright © 2010 by
Roberto Torretti <>

Open access to the SEP is made possible by a world-wide funding initiative.
Please Read How You Can Help Keep the Encyclopedia Free

The SEP would like to congratulate the National Endowment for the Humanities on its 50th anniversary and express our indebtedness for the five generous grants it awarded our project from 1997 to 2007. Readers who have benefited from the SEP are encouraged to examine the NEH’s anniversary page and, if inspired to do so, send a testimonial to